Wealthy Habitat

Tools · Investing

Roth versus traditional

The same contribution through two kinds of account. Type your numbers and the answer follows, with the formula beside it so you can redo it by hand. Nothing is stored and nobody is told what to do.

$
%
%
%
yrs

Traditional, after tax at the end: $475,789. [full contribution grows, then × (1 − later rate)]

Roth, after tax at the end: $475,789. [contribution × (1 − today's rate) grows, untaxed at the end]

Difference, Roth minus traditional: $0. [roth − traditional] the whole difference comes from the two tax rates; equal rates give equal results.

The same pre tax dollars either way, flat tax rates, and no employer match. The real question is the rate later, which nobody knows; this shows what each guess implies.

The numbers travel in the link itself; nothing is stored anywhere.

Was this useful? Counted, never signed.

A worked example

With pre tax dollars set aside each year at $6,000, tax rate today at 22 percent, tax rate when it comes out at 22 percent, growth each year at 7 percent, years at 30 years: traditional, after tax at the end comes to $475,789; roth, after tax at the end comes to $475,789; difference, Roth minus traditional comes to $0.

What the formula says

Traditional, after tax at the end. Full contribution grows, then × (1 − later rate).

Roth, after tax at the end. Contribution × (1 − today's rate) grows, untaxed at the end.

Difference, Roth minus traditional. Roth − traditional. The whole difference comes from the two tax rates; equal rates give equal results.

The same pre tax dollars either way, flat tax rates, and no employer match. The real question is the rate later, which nobody knows; this shows what each guess implies.

The idea behind it is explained in the guide Roth or traditional: two jars, one tax bill.

Rules behind it

The Roth IRA and its income phase out
The traditional IRA and the deduction phase out
The Roth 401(k) option inside the plan

Nearby calculators