Wealthy Habitat

Tools · Debt, home, and car

Rent or buy

The two paths side by side, with every cost named. Type your numbers and the answer follows, with the formula beside it so you can redo it by hand. Nothing is stored and nobody is told what to do.

$
%
$
%
%
%
%
%
%
yrs

Rent paid over the years: $165,509. [rent × 12 each year, rising by the rent increase]

Cost of owning over the years: $140,963. [interest + taxes, insurance, upkeep + closing costs + 6 percent selling cost − price gain] principal paid is not a cost; it comes back as equity.

Growth given up on the down payment and closing costs: $13,143. [(down payment + closing costs) × ((1 + growth)^years − 1)] the growth is an assumption you set, not a forecast.

Equity at sale: $109,547. [sale price − selling cost − loan balance]

Difference, owning minus renting: −$11,404. [owning cost + growth given up − rent paid] below zero means owning cost less over these years at these assumptions.

A thirty year loan, six percent selling costs, and steady rates of rent increase, price change, and growth, all assumptions you set. The growth given up counts the down payment and closing costs only: the monthly difference between owning and renting costs is not invested. It leaves out the tax treatment of either path.

The numbers travel in the link itself; nothing is stored anywhere.

Was this useful? Counted, never signed.

A worked example

With rent each month at $1,800, rent rises each year at 3 percent, home price at $320,000, down payment at 10 percent, closing costs to buy, share of price at 3 percent, mortgage rate at 6.5 percent, taxes, insurance, and upkeep, as a share of price each year at 2.5 percent, home price rises each year at 3 percent, growth each year on money not put into the home at 4 percent, years you would stay at 7 years: rent paid over the years comes to $165,509; cost of owning over the years comes to $140,963; growth given up on the down payment and closing costs comes to $13,143; equity at sale comes to $109,547; difference, owning minus renting comes to −$11,404.

What the formula says

Rent paid over the years. Rent × 12 each year, rising by the rent increase.

Cost of owning over the years. Interest + taxes, insurance, upkeep + closing costs + 6 percent selling cost − price gain. Principal paid is not a cost; it comes back as equity.

Growth given up on the down payment and closing costs. (down payment + closing costs) × ((1 + growth)^years − 1). The growth is an assumption you set, not a forecast.

Equity at sale. Sale price − selling cost − loan balance.

Difference, owning minus renting. Owning cost + growth given up − rent paid. Below zero means owning cost less over these years at these assumptions.

A thirty year loan, six percent selling costs, and steady rates of rent increase, price change, and growth, all assumptions you set. The growth given up counts the down payment and closing costs only: the monthly difference between owning and renting costs is not invested. It leaves out the tax treatment of either path.

Nearby calculators