Library · Real estate · Published 10/10/2026 · Read again by the automated checks 10/10/2026
Rental property: cap rate and cash on cash
Cap rate shows what a property earns if bought with cash, while cash on cash shows what your invested dollars earn after the mortgage.
In short
You have probably looked at a rental property and felt a good gut feeling, the kind that says this place could work. A gut feeling is a fine place to start. Two numbers will tell you more than your gut ever could. Cap rate and cash on cash return are those two numbers. A friend of mine wrote them on an index card and kept it in his truck. You can learn them in an afternoon.
The whole of it
What it is
A friend of mine used to say that a number without context is just noise. Cap rate, short for capitalization rate, is the yearly return a property would earn if you paid all cash, with no loan at all. Cash on cash return is a different animal. It measures what your own invested dollars earn after you pay the mortgage. Both are percentages. Both let you compare one property to another on fair ground.
You have probably sensed there is a gap between the property itself and the deal you make on it. That instinct is right. Cap rate looks at the property as if no loan existed. Cash on cash looks at your deal, with your loan, your down payment, and your closing costs all counted in.
How it works
I once watched a man spend three hours on paint colors and ten minutes on the finances of a rental he was about to buy. He lost money for two years straight. The math is not hard. You just have to do it.
For cap rate, you start with net operating income, which people call NOI. That is what the property earns after its operating costs but before any mortgage payment. Operating costs include property taxes, insurance, repairs, management fees, and vacancy loss. Vacancy loss is the rent you expect to miss when the unit sits empty between tenants. Subtract all of those from your gross rent, and what is left is NOI.
If you are working through this right now, the next step is simple. Divide NOI by the purchase price. You get a decimal. Multiply it by 100 to get a percentage. Say NOI is $9,000 and the price is $150,000. Divide $9,000 by $150,000 and you get 0.06. That is a 6 percent cap rate.
Cash on cash takes one more step. First, find your annual pre tax cash flow. That is what remains after you pay the mortgage too, not just the operating costs. Then divide it by the cash you actually put into the deal. That cash includes your down payment, your closing costs, and any repair money you spend before the first tenant moves in. A small cash flow over a big pile of cash gives a small return. The same cash flow over a smaller pile gives a better one. Same house, different deal.
The numbers, and where to find yours
You have probably wondered where all these inputs come from. Cap rate and cash on cash are not set by any law. No government page gives you a number to plug in. The inputs, though, all come from places you can check.
Your property tax figure comes from the county assessor's office or the actual tax bill. Get it in writing. Your insurance cost comes from a real quote, not a guess. Your management fee comes from your contract, if you hire a manager. Collect bids from a few local firms first. One firm may charge quite a bit more than another across the county.
Your mortgage payment depends on three things: your loan amount, your interest rate, and your loan term. A basic mortgage calculator will get you close. Your lender will give you the exact figure.
Vacancy is the input people skip. Please do not skip it. The Census Bureau publishes a Housing Vacancy Survey that includes rental vacancy rates. Your city planning office may also post local data. Look it up rather than assume.
A friend once told me he trusted the seller's numbers because the seller seemed decent. That is a kind thought. It is not a safe one. Sellers build their projections to make the deal look good. Yours should be built to tell the truth.
A worked example
If you are holding a listing sheet right now, walk through this with me and a woman named Maria.
Maria finds a single family rental listed at $180,000. The seller says it rents for $1,600 a month. Maria checks comparable rentals nearby and decides $1,500 a month is realistic. That gives her gross rent of $1,500 times 12, which is $18,000 a year.
She adds up her operating costs. Property taxes are $2,200 a year. Insurance is $900. She budgets $800 for repairs. She will manage the house herself, so the management fee is $0. She assumes 8 percent vacancy, which is $18,000 times 0.08, or $1,440. Her total operating costs are $2,200 plus $900 plus $800 plus $1,440, which comes to $5,340.
Her NOI is $18,000 minus $5,340, which is $12,660.
Her cap rate is $12,660 divided by $180,000. That is 0.0703, or about 7 percent.
Now for cash on cash. She puts 20 percent down. That is $180,000 times 0.20, or $36,000. Her closing costs are $3,200. Her pre rental repairs are $1,800. Her total cash invested is $36,000 plus $3,200 plus $1,800, which is $41,000.
She borrows the other $144,000. Her mortgage payment is $780 a month. That is $780 times 12, or $9,360 a year. Her pre tax cash flow is $12,660 minus $9,360, which is $3,300.
She divides $3,300 by $41,000. Her cash on cash return is 0.0805, or about 8 percent.
Maria now knows what she is buying. That is the whole point.
Where it goes wrong
I once heard it said that optimism is a fine virtue until it meets a leaky roof. Trouble with these numbers tends to come from a few places.
A friend of mine learned that a seller's rent estimate can be a wish dressed up as a fact. Sellers want a high number. You want a true one. Check local listings and ask a property manager for an honest opinion before you write anything down.
New landlords often skip vacancy, skip repairs, or guess low on management costs. Every one of those gaps makes a deal look better on paper than it will in real life. Try this with Maria's house. At 2 percent vacancy, her vacancy loss is $360, and her NOI climbs to $13,740. At 8 percent, it is the $12,660 we found above. Run both. That extra step has spared plenty of people a nasty surprise.
You have probably noticed that cap rate and cash on cash sound alike. They are not twins. Cap rate ignores your financing. Cash on cash counts it. A property can show a solid cap rate and a weak cash on cash return if the loan is large or the rate is high. Both numbers together tell the story. Neither one alone is enough.
If your inputs are soft, your answers will be soft too. Give them the same honest care you would give any big choice in your life.
Questions to answer before you leave this page
You have done the reading, and now I would ask you to sit with a few honest questions, because a good question asked now is worth ten regrets asked later. Can you get the actual property tax bill from the county assessor instead of taking the seller's word for it? Do you have at least one real insurance quote for this exact property? Have you collected bids from local property managers so your fee is a real number? Have you looked up rental vacancy data for your area from the Census Bureau or your local planning office? Did you verify the rent yourself from comparable active listings? Did you count every dollar you will put in, including closing costs and repair money, when you figured cash on cash? And when the numbers come back lower than you hoped, are you willing to walk away, or does the gut feeling still have the wheel?
Now work it with your own numbers. Mortgage payment and total cost, the payment, and what the loan costs over its life · Rent or buy, the two paths side by side, with every cost named. Each shows the formula it used.
Learn it in steps. The course called Your money, understood begins with Money you can lose, money you cannot: two short paragraphs, one number of your own, and a check, about five minutes on the page. No account needed.
Related
Landlording: the real time cost
Mortgages: fixed, ARM, points, PMI
Depreciation and recapture
See something wrong on this page? Write to admin@wealthyhabitat.com and say which sentence.
Was this useful? Counted, never signed.
Ask about this guide
A model reads this page and answers from it. It will say when the answer is not on the page. Education, not personalized advice.
Written by the site's growth engine and checked by its gates: voice, law and ethics, facts, arithmetic, and sources. Not yet read by a human editor, and a correction goes to the address above. Rules and dollar limits change every year; figures come from the table of yearly figures with their source and date.